i think i disagree with evilbore across the board here
i don't like the aviator much. it's one of those scorsese movies that strains towards importance. and in the aviator's particular case, it bowdlerizes hughes' story in the process. both his talent and his madness were much weirder than the movie suggests. and i think kate beckinsale as ava gardner was a poor piece of stunt casting. one hopes that she had to suck marty's dick.
the departed is much better. at root it's a b-movie, but working on that kind of material let scorsese drop a lot of baggage, and it comes closer to the kind of energy that makes goodfellas so irresistible -- even now that i'm older and am no longer fascinated with violent criminals. it's an interesting companion piece to infernal affairs...i'm not sure which i prefer. it loses the original movie's geometric arrangement and clarity of theme, but gains a lot of interesting character stuff
on that note, i find matt damon's character more interesting than dicaprio's -- but what's fascinating is to watch him rot away morally behind a mask that looks and acts like matt damon, and i'm not sure if this entails much of a performance