First-person view really would suit this game better. I guess they wanted to do something to separate themselves from the competition, but all we got were two boring character model types and controls that are more like a FPS than a third person action/shooter. You have to play around with the controls and find the right control scheme for you (get rid of the motion controls, stat!), and once you get used to them, the controls do the job nicely. The Warhawks themselves are a joy to fly around with. I think the game makes for a better Battlefield-style experience than Battlefield 2 on the 360 did, but in the end there are better shooters out there. It's nice to have the game on the HDD and mess around with it on occasion, plus it has more players online (a LOT more players) at any given time unlike say, UT3.
Oh, and the DLC is pretty damn cool.