Just Started it. Its good, nut in no way is it scary.
Hopefully my copy arrives soon so I can post my own impressions of Dead Space, rather than relating them to Bioshock or System Shock 2, but:
What's "scary" only relates to how much I'm immersed, or
let myself be immersed in the game. This can be influenced by personal phobias; darkness is pretty much ubiquitous, but the shark in Half Life 1 just about made me stop playing, and the spiders in SS2
did make my friend quit the game. But in any case, it's all just pixels on a screen and sounds.
So are you just saying, "games arent' scary," or are you saying Dead Space is specifically lame in the scary department?