Deerhunter is pretty meh. If I had the yearning to listen to Deerhunter, I'd probably put in a record by one of the several better bands that have similar influences but are, well, better, like Pacement, SY, or The Fall or something. I'm not sure it would have ended up on any sort of my best of list since they are somewhat contrary to my personal aesthetic, but the Fleet Foxes record is really good stuff. I'm not sure how much you will like it, PD. It's pretty much inarguably White People Music.
Also, non-rap sites just shouldn't include rap on their lists. I really hope that someone at Pitchfork feels embarrassed by that Weezy pick a year or two from now.