i finished it first time and i quite enjoyed it,it was okay
"GO AND FIND THE MCGUFFIN SO WE CAN UNLOCK THE GUFFIN BOAT REQUIRED TO REACH GUFFIN ISLAND" it's a standard rpg,nothing special besides the ultra awesome level 5 visuals... good but not great
i tried to replay it two month ago and i stopped after acquiring the boat,ultra-annoyed at the amount of random battles (i swear you can't even get off the boat that by the time you turn back you have been attacked at least once) i hate how dragon quest is more than happy to drop you in battle with more than 6 or 7 enemies,some battles take forever in DQ8 (and dare to say some older dragon quest like DQ3 too) because there is twice the amount of baddies x battle than in a standard rpg!
i told myself "i already know what comes next (hint: it was a really annoying boss) what's the point to continue?"