I like convex and concave both. I think it depends on how the sticks are made and positioned. Like, I don't mind the convex sticks on the PS3 or Gamecube/Wii, but the logitech convex sticks are awful, same with the Dreamcast and N64 ones. The 360 sticks are good but I wish there were a bit more rounded since I don't have huge hands and my thumbs often just push the bottom left stick instead of sitting on top of the controller. The xbox s controller is the best; analog sticks are a medium between convex and concave.
The dreamcast analog stick is the worst. I'm still amazed that they designed it like that, especially after the Saturn 3D controller had a more comfortable concave stick. I wish I bought a 3rd party controller at one point.
remember that fps controller from a few years ago?
this thing?
(Image removed from quote.)
i almost fell for it and bought one
almost
haha, my friend bought one of those for Mace Griffin Bounty Hunter
I remember thinking the idea was neat (most buttons accessible at the same time with your other fingers) but that's about it.