You guys are a crazy bunch of Suda fans. I don't understand how someone who digs Suda's style and what he tries to do can like 1 game and not like the other.
I like all his games. Killer 7, NMH, Samurai Champloo, even Blood+ was decent. I couldn't get into Flower, Sun Rain on the DS (probably cause my used cartridge smelled like cigarettes [maybe intentional?]) but I wouldn't write it off either; I know people who loved it on PS2.
Suda uses the game medium as an art form and also he doesn't seem to give a fuck about the video"game" part, since they all play pretty shitty

He's pushing the medium the way very few designers do. Though his games play like simple series 2000 titles, I'd put him up there with Kojima and Ueda because he tries to make a videogame more than just a game.
His composer is also fuck awesome.