I've actually only really liked him in Uncharted. The other stuff he has worked on has been okay voice wise but nothing that I really overly paid attention to.
He does have an ability to speak normally rather than in stilted video game voicework in a booth type stuff most voice actors deliver so I understand why people keep trying to get him but just like acting the role still has to be suited for him. Uncharted works with him because it feels like the whole game world has been designed around the personality of that voice. The rest of these games using him don't.