Finally got a chance to raid with the guild. The MT couldn't make it so I tanked the BWD 25 man. First week the guild has been doing 25 man in fact; yesterday they killed Omnotron Defense System. Two shotted Magmaw, then started Maloriak. I was on the boss initially, but the off tank was failing with the adds so they switched me with him. Perfect situation: not only does the guild MT not show up, but the off tank screws up enough to make the raid leader test me out in his spot. I thought I did good: no one was complaining about getting hit, I was kiting like a pro etc (Heroic Leap comes in handy here). Buut eventually the amount of adds constantly became overwhelming and I'd die.
After a wipes and a horribly long wait for one player to finish a phone call, we decided to put two tanks on the adds - one on each side. Healing seemed to stabilize, but during the second green phase I wound up dying as we AOE'd them down. People were tired/upset after that so the raid leader called it.
Definitely think we'll get it easily next time with two tanks on adds. All the how-to videos I saw were for 10 man, so I was expecting nine adds at the most, which I could just stun and kite until the green phase. But we were getting a shit ton more.
at least I got some tank boots from Magmaw lol