I love Shadow of the Colossus. Diablos is an idiot who only fought one colossi. I am pretty sure he took 30 minutes to find out how to kill it. Mother fucker.
I compare OotW to ICO because of how the games have partners that you use to solve puzzles, and it's another opportunity to waste that overrated piece of poopy. OotW didn't use a partner that I wanted to murder though.
I tried to play ICO and just couldn't. Shadow Of the Colossus didn't even interest me. I was watching a friend play it recently, and he's just riding around this huge, EMPTY world looking for the monsters. I sat there wondering how it was any fun roaming around an overworld devoid of life.
That's one of my problems with the game. It's a two edged sword. On one hand, it adds to the atmosphere because it feels as if you're the only guy out there, and you're trying to kill these wonderful "beasts" who didn't do shit to you; On the other, there's a lack of things to do outside of finding the bosses. They could have easily made the game puzzle oriented and over took Zelda but nope. It's nothing but boss gauntlet. If they added puzzles and platforming before each Colossus, it would have been so much better.