That's a shame : (
And no, you don't have to call, you unsocial NERD
It's not that these games are bad, it's just I've already played them and if I wanted them their physical copies are pretty cheap. DR2, Fable 3, AC2, and Crackdown, all probably sub $20 at your local Gamestop. I mean I'm not a fan of PSN+ but hey Sleeping Dogs I think was given away and that's kind of recent. Battlefield 3, hey that's a game that's still worth diving into. I just think PSN+ has given away better games. Plus a lot more digital only stuff.
Plus I honestly haven't played an online game on XBL in forever.
And yeah it's funny, every time I try to cancel online on the website it says there's an error. A Google search reveals tons of people having this problem, with the common advice being "just call".