Mass Effect and Mirror's Edge hate hurts my soul. Those are probably my top two console games from that gen...pretty easily in my top ten favorite ever, too. I beat Mass Effect something like 24 times. I would come home from class, throw an album on, and zone out into muscle memory. The atmosphere, plot, soundtrack, and characterization of that game...damn. It was janky as all hell but it would still be an A+ if it were a hundred times worse because of those elements. Virmire --> Ilos --> Citadel is the best stretch of any game, ever. Mirror's Edge was just something new and fun and atmospheric. The atrium puzzle is a perfect moment.
Last gen's second crop of games with Mass Effect, Mirror's Edge, Dead Space, Forza 2, Skate, Crackdown, Burnout Paradise, Geometry Wars 2, Assassin's Creed, Viva Pinata ...

Creative wildfire brehs. GOAT console generation.