If I had to guess, Evilore checked out and let mods have more freedom to do what they want. I doubt Evilore has favoritism towards as many users as some mods do, same thing with petty vendettas or grievances (Evilore can be petty, but its usually more private and retardedly nuanced).
Evilore is to blame for not keeping the mods on an actual leash, the mods are to blame for enforcing their own rules which are actually complete garbage and have hurt the site tremendously.