This thread and playing Infamous First Light for free lately (thanks to PS+) has got me thinking about how weak Sony's 1st party stuff has been on PS4 so far:
Killzone - Graphics great, gunplay good, multiplayer decent, good campaign length, lots of content....but the level design is shit and narrative is shit, so the campaign is miserably bad.
Knack - Game is good, fuck you all
Infamous SS - Graphics pretty good (hate the inconsistent framerate, it's bugging me so much in FL, hovers around 40fps), but no multiplayer, campaign is very light on content and narrative sucks; pretty forgettable game that's pretty to look at but dull to play and a big step down from fun gameplay-driven Infamous 2 and that vampire one.
Driveclub - Very solid racer that was a disaster at launch, great graphics, good gameplay, decent campaign length, good multiplayer; could use some more content but about on par with PGR3
The Order - graphics great, gunplay sounds ok?, no multiplayer, short campaign, weak level design and weak narrative for a weak campaign with no other content so game is bad
Upcoming for 2015:
Bloodborne - Will probably be good since it's not really a Sony game and From's been consistent lately
Uncharted 4 - Probably good since ND has a good track record and is probably smart enough to not focus entirely on graphics, graphics, graphics at the expense of an actual good game underneath
Pretty mixed bag. Feels like they need some tightening in on publisher control on some of these games. Make sure they have enough content for what the market requires, make sure they WORK at launch, and double check that the game isn't less "fun" than its predecessor. Some of them seem like they could be ok 7/10 or 8/10 starts for 9/10 sequels like Driveclub, Knack or Infamous if the jump is a Inf1 -> Inf2 gameplay upgrade. But honestly I'd rather see Infamous guys do something else for their next game as I think they've ran this train dry with the series and there probably shouldn't be an Order 2 from the sounds of it. I'm also glad that Killzone appears dead and the guys are making a Dragons Dogma game instead.
Hopefully some of this is just first year fuck ups where they put the wrong priorities to focus on graphical wow to sell consoles over quality gameplay and content. If Uncharted fucks up it'll be pretty bad for their 1st party track record, but then Knack 2 and its GoTY awards it will win will save them in the end.
Yeah I dunno why I wrote all that.