I remember refreshing the GAFforums on Weekday mornings, getting tons of new infos about upcoming titles, covers of upcoming titles in america and japan, industry insider interviews, tech infos...
The forum really felt connected to the industry, it really had that insider edge. The gameplay threads were amazing. I remember MAF's thread about Morrowind; it convinced me to buy a freaking xbox with Halo and that game back in the days.
The fact that the last couple of 'insider rumors' threads on the forum turned out to be complete bullshit is certainly not helping the credibility of a so-called nexus of hardcore gamers, enthusiast press, and video game industry developers and publishers.
Nowadays There are more breaking news threads about new burgers available at McDonald in the OT section than actual legit industry threads in the gaming section. I certainly feel that I'm up to date to the newest pepsi flavors and KFC specials.
it's really lame that it went to shit like that.