I like to think Del Toro would have kept Silent Hills somewhat on the rails, at least not let Kojima totally kill the mood every 5 minutes.
I don't even know why DelToro was involved, tbh.
Granted i watched most of his movies, and only liked 3, but his style and Silent Hill's aren't really close.
And then people mention the creature design, which drives me nuts, it's not like he's a concept artist, he has people like Sergio Sandoval drawing up designs which he then approves.
It'd be like saying that George Lucas, instead of Ralph McQuarrie or Ian McCaig (or one of the other million artists involved), came up with Star Wars' visual designs/costumes/looks.
Ofc. that's the role of a director, put everything into place, but i'm saying his role within Silent Hills, when you already have such a strong personality like Kojima's, doing that, is lost on me.
Junji Ito's involvement made more sense from that point of view, since his expertise is more specialized, even though i don't see his style as very compatible either, his tone of horror is usually gross-out and comedic in nature, whereas Silent Hill at his peak is gross in a more abstract manner (and if you look up Masahiro Ito's personal work, even his Mecha artworks scream Silent Hill).
To me, it seems like Kojima is always after the biggest name he can get, like if Beksinski was still alive, he would've gotten him, probably.
