Yeah, thats been my stance all along.
S1 >>>> S3 > S2
S1 for me is just television greatness. Its still a very good show, but its lacking that intimacy, and that undescribable "thing", or intangible, that it used to have. Basically it was an absolutely brilliant show that has slunk down to become merely a very good one.
Kristen Bell still rocks it though, as does Dohring. But they've made Logan/V drama the center of the show WAY TOO MUCH. Personally, I hate schmoopy, pussy whipped Logan. Him and V work best when they are not together, and sniping at eachother, and you can still feel the sexual tension.