It's not about being an xbot.
I'll level with you. Aside from being an upscaling dvd player, media streamer, and Live Arcade machine, it is little else. Most of the 360 library, while containing some quality, doesnt hold my attention.
I wouldn't mind if Sony failed, someone has to. MS cant fail because it hasnt ever really succeeded, and Nintendo is off in the corner doing its own thing which is completely outside of the equation. So up till this point the only company that hasn't failed yet is Sony, and they're due.
'yes MAF but they arent DOOMED'
Who is to say? Back when Sega was popular I dont think people would have imagined them in the position they are in today. They never WON the system wars but they were a strong force. Being 'DOOMED' in this industry isn't about going bankrupt and living in a hooverville, it's about being somewhere or in a position you don't want to be in. As a consumer I look at these points:
600 dollars
New and UNPROVEN medium (shades of UMD here)
Questionable Launch Line-Up
Limited number of units at launch falling into the hands of scalpers
Broken Promises to Developers
Lots of METOO tacked on technology not initially MEANT for the system
Broken Promises to Fans
A controller called PooS. Thats just silly.
Weird Draconian limitations demonstrated in the past (2D oldschool games on ps2 in America)
The price to me, is the biggest issue. It says 600 dollars, and I see 800 dollars. 360 didnt cost 400 at launch, it cost 600. There's all the stuff we STILL HAVE TO BUY. I have a GOOD job, and that price seems INSANE. This isn't something families will be able to afford easily in a country drowning in debt and struggling with job security. So it comes down to the super-fans, which are currently supporting the PSP, and I dont think thats enough to meet Sony's PS3 sale predictions.
I have a feeling Nintendo is going to make up an incredible amount of lost ground this next gen through the WalMart families alone. 360 will probably continue to perform as it is now until its lifespan is run through, in the event the PS3 TANKS, which is possible, the 360 might just benefit from that situation.
This isnt about being a fanboy, its about having reservations about an 800 dollar expense and understanding that as a statistic, there are LOTS of people out there that feel the same.