Nothing beats my shitty rental: Back in the day, Total Recall. Thank god I didn't buy it!!! Also rented Hydlide from the same place. Small, local video store that has long since closed, they had an awesome NES selection, I rented so many amazing games from them like Mega Man 2, Dragon Warrior, Faxanadu, etc
I never even heard of THE DARKNESS till Willco started pimping it on this here site...