lmao
Why do most MGS diehards assume every MGS fan likes MGS for the same reason they do?
I'm not in it for the sci-fi Japanese melodrama and never really have besides MGS1.
Metal Gear Solid series has silly things, but not all silly things are equal.
Having a psychic dude take control of Meryl and use her to her aim gun at you, change the video screen to HIDEO, and have chairs fly around? Silly, but cool as fuck.
Having a dude get naked after being tortured and sneak around without getting caught while his boss spazzes out screaming SCISSORS 61? Silly, and pretty fucking hilarious.
Having a lightning dude chase you on you a mobile nuke tank? Awesome!
Everything in MGS4? Really fucking lame. Everything
after MGS4?
Really fucking lame.
Silly does not negate criticism. MGS4 is a terrible game, both gameplay and story-wise. It shits on the lore of the franchise while offering nothing to gameplay fans of the series.
Personally, MGS4 was so offensive in its story, that I gave up all hope on MGS5 having remotely a likeable story. The thing about MGS stories is that they're likeable, but just that. I'm not going to replay MGS for story.
Wanna know what I'm going to replay MGS for? Speed runnin', Big Bossin', S rankin', No killin', No alertin', Extreme modin', dog taggn' swagger. The people that equate MGS to, as you said, a roller coaster ride, ain't in it for that.
If that's the cutscene I think it is, where Ocelot unleashes nanomachines, or whatever, on the boat. How can I not love it? Because it's shit. It's not even entertaining. It takes itself so seriously, without a modicum of understanding its pretentious shittinness. Fighting Sniper Wolf is silly. Will love bloom on a battlefield?

Who cares, but it's cool as shit. The Sorrow is cool. The End is cool. Even at its most silly, MGS managed to be cool. Until Fukushima up and left and Kojima thought he could take the reins for himself. If it's going to be silly, it should be
aware it's silly. If not that, it should at least be entertaining. 90 minute cutscenes isn't entertaining.
MGS4 was a roller coaster ride.
And that's exactly why it was a shit MGS.
MGS games are not roller coaster rides. They're stealth game where the roller coaster ride is merely the side effect. At least for me. S-rankin', elite stealthin', extreme modin', speed runnin' is my main priority in MGS. Roller coaster rides?

MGSV's honey bee mission on hard mode is a better MGS experience than the entirety of MGS4 for me. People say V is a bad MGS game, but the gameplay is what I define a good MGS to be.
Thank fuck for MGSV causing the story MGS fans to explode. Jesus Christ, it's about time they caught up with the rest of us. The rest of us are all about dat gameplay and have been since MGS2.