I don't get how anybody liked the original PS2 games honestly, the gameplay was garbage.
back on topic, is it possible to play this without the original GTA4 disk?
Yes, every single piece of news on the topic has hammered this home: the DLC requires the original disc, but if you buy the two-pack of
Ballad of Gay Tony/Lost and the Damned, it is completely standalone, playable without the original disc.
The part where it's unclear is if the standalone disc version's Achievements count as separate titles -- can players double-up on Achievements through both DLC and disc playthrough?
What about multiplayer? Can
BoGT/TLatD disc players join multiplayer games with GTA4 players? If not, what about GTA4+DLC players?
Last night I tried playing multiplayer activated out of a TLatD savefile. My online character model had a HUGE number of
new costumes, mostly biker themed. When I tried to join a Ranked Deathmatch game, historically the easiest game to find, there were -no- players. One guy joined and we sat there for a couple minutes waiting for new players. No go. So I think GTA4 multiplayer gets limited by whatever DLC is activated. I definitely want to roll back into whatever environment which allows connecting with the most players.