RDR is pretty great. I think it does a lot better than GTAV in some areas. Mainly in the random element and the quest writing, which were all pretty boring to bad in GTAV and had none of the distinct quality of RDR's.
Bully is a pretty solid game. It's heavily inspired by Shenmue, but with a less focused narrative. I didn't care for it much when it came out, because I had played Shenmue 1 and 2 earlier that year for the first time and I didn't think it stacked up. I'm really interested in giving it another shot, because in hindsight, and in terms of general concept, it appeals to me. Maybe this time it won't be colored by my experience of playing Shenmue 1, but that game in general ruins a lot of open world games for me.
Apparently Bully on Steam has a very positive grade, so I'll check it out soon.