Christ, the game doesn't have dialog trees, but it manages to FUCK THAT UP pretty well.
Level 38, cruising The Depths finally, and ONLY JUST NOW getting to the pyromancer. I've had a lvl 1 catalyst for pyro this whole time, and only FIREBALL 8 castings -- This hasn't felt like a stellar class decision for me, so far.
So I save the guy, he thanks me, and I promptly fall down a whole and have to deal with a couple of new enemies I've never seen before, and piles of oozing feces all over the place.
Finally, I make it out of The Depths, and back to Firelink, where the pyro teacher is available at last!
"Oh, hey. I'm a cool guy with a British accent, and I'm kind of casual for a death-dealing wizard, but ho, what ho, I'll teach you some of my spells. What do you say? Unless you find magic unappealing?"
WHAT DO YOU ANSWER:
[YES] [NO]
Wat? wat-wat-wat? which was the question, and is this an idiomatic use of the negative? YES OR NO?
Well, every other person so far has been a YES answer to get access to their stuff, so... YES."Oh, right. OK, sorry, how horrible of me. I'll just sit here and do nothing then."
spoiler (click to show/hide)
I have to say "NO" to get your stuff, for which I've waited 38 levels? I quit before the game could save the result, just in case, and restarted.
Pyro catalyst to +3, an extra scroll of Fireball, so I have 16 castings now, and Incendiary or whatever the melee fire strike is. YES. "'Now I have a machine gun, too. Ho-ho-ho.'"