It's really a subjective opinion. Picking between the two is like picking between newborns. It's impossible. Some days I'm feeling 90's action, some days I'm feeling 80's action. Neither is superior, just different.
You can cite Judge Dredd all you want but that doesn't stop Rumble in the Bronx, Demolition Man, Die Hard With a Vengeance, Hard Boiled, Terminator 2, Speed, The Rock, The Matrix, Timecop et al from existing.