The next-gen software thing is simply a point of too much competition (and here people said next-gen has no games). CoD/BF4 are fighting each other and stealing all the thunder from any other FPS games like Killzone.
What's interesting is that you would have thought XB having an exclusive FPS at launch would be a no brainer, since that's MS' audience. Even X360 had PDZ and Condemned. Yet, it turns out not having one was a smarter move because when you have CoD and BF, no one cares about a 3rd pillar FPS game. It was smart saving Halo 5 as their year 1 game. It'll do a lot better than The Order I think.
Then you have a dozen decent sellers all pulling the remaining sales from "purchase game #2 or #3" and you end up with everyone getting a little bite of the pie but no big hitters besides those. ACIV was the 2nd buy or 3rd buy game for most people.
Also from the gaf thread:
Knack didn't break 100k (at retail...). Is selling better than internal expectations.
Ps4 was about 200k over xb1. Barely moved 100k the rest of the month after launch. Sacrificing huge NA lead for huge WW lead. Xb1 will win December
1) Sad, but not surprised Knack didn't break 100k. It really should've been a pack in/bundle in the US like it was in Europe. People in the US don't buy games like Knack, especially when they get terrible reviews across the board. Really surprised that it's selling better than internal expectations. Why even make the game if you're only expecting 50-100k sales? I guess WW numbers will save it and I really, really want a Knack 2 as it's a good original IP in a genre that Sony needs more of now that Ratchet is gone; maybe not though. Could end up not selling enough to greenlight a sequel. But then Gravity Daze is getting a sequel so who knows...
2) December NPD is going to be a bloodbath. I really don't know if this strategy by Sony is a good one. US is so fiercely competitive, and so Xbox land, that giving them the lead early on seems incredibly risky since it could snowball where people buy XB as their next-gen system and then all their friends are on XB so they choose it too. Sure it'll be nice to help build Sony's lead worldwide, but US is still the biggest market and one where they got beat down bad last gen. I think they really need to get a lot of units back in the US in the next couple of months or risk people losing interest after the launch hype has gone. If not, they better pump MILLIONS into marketing Infamous & Driveclub and then have a huge flourish of systems on shelfs along with those in the US to start moving the systems again.
My 2cents.