I haven't read that thread since I was posting helpful alternative scenarios earlier, but it was amusing how many of the responses were assuming either/and:
1. Leaving the list was some kind of passive-aggressive move to TELL HIM SOMETHING.
2. That she carries about a list of people she's banged constantly and how this is INSANE. THERE'S NO POSSIBLE EXPLANATION FOR EVER MAKING A LIST!
3. That she's constantly spending time with ALL TEN OF THESE GUYS ALL THE TIME AND WITH HIM THERE.
4. After you have sex with someone you can't ever associate with them again.
Plus the dudes who were all "END IT BRO, YOU CAN'T ALLOW THIS KIND OF THING, I'D KICK HER OUT IMMEDIATELY" as if there wasn't anything worse than possibly willful obfuscation.