I KNEW you'd comment on Sensible Soccer DCharles, I think that was a pretty much British thing and very little of us were playing it so it wasnt exactly a mainstream hit. Loved that game 
Sensi was good, but Sensible World of Soccer took it to an all new dimension of awesome.
We played it to death in our student house - all of us in the inter house league. We keep it going on and on , watching each other play and trying to psych each other out. When we played each other it was a complete event.
Many games came and went that we loved, but Sensi was ever present and meant the Amiga survived all the way through uni life.
And yeah - it's definitely a british thing i think.
Edit : oh god , yeah - one other thing that we had.... we had two joysticks. A Kempston Pro (the KING of joysticks) and a sort of Quickshot clone stick (pretty poor for sensi, used more for flight sims etc). To help simulate the rigours of real football, the house rule was that all away games had to be played on the Quickshot. Mayhem. Drama. Police Cars.