So you agree that you can't read for shit because I clearly said "a lot" not "all"?
The problem is we don't know what Ronito is even referring to. Is he talking about the thread where dude cuts out his alt right friend for not liking Muslims? I don't know. I can only assume. So I went with that because his post was a shit post.
Except for the fact that just after that you talked about "anti-Islamists" as if they're bigots and mentioned Maher who, like many atheists, has always had a problem with Islam and its followers because of what the religion represents not because he doesn't like brown people which has always been clear as day.
Errrr...a lot of assuming here.
The context was within the alt right. Alt right's criticisms of Islam goes beyond criticism. The reason I brought up the alt right to begin with was a thread on gaf. Seemed to me that Ronito assumed that an alt right supporter who doesn't like Islam should be accepted because it's criticism and criticism is warranted. I didn't know wtf he was referring to.
Criticism towards Islam is both legitimate and also illegitimate. Not all criticism for Islam is equal. Anti-Islamists aren't necessarily racist or even bigots. But I do feel that certain critics of Islam like Maher and Harris definitely are racist in their critcisim. Not always, but a lot of the time. I argue this because of times like when the kid Ahmed was arrested for bringing the clock and Maher justified having the kid arrested because he brought a clock to school. Maher wraps his argument in being hard on Islam, but ignores a racial component that exists. When called out in, he says it's not about race.
It isn't that criticism towards Islam means you're a bigot or a racist, but there's definitely a segment of Islam critics who definitely apply broad strokes such as Christolher Hitchens with a racist aspect to their argument.
This entire page you have done assumption after assumption both to wrath and me. What is this about? What are you even arguing?
You think that I think all criticism towards Islam is racist? Do you even know who I am? Do you not realize that I am also an atheist that is critical of Islam? I have waxed over anti-semitism in Islam more than once over the years. But you wouldn't know because you're starting meaningless fights over shit you who knows what. You just decided to jump into this thread in the middle of a conversation with people who have been talking to each other for 10-ish years. What are you even arguing?