Okay, bruhs, let's get down to brass tacks here. Who's got the best villagers?
(Image removed from quote.) (Image removed from quote.) (Image removed from quote.)
(Image removed from quote.) (Image removed from quote.) (Image removed from quote.)
spoiler (click to show/hide)
But I
need to get Raymond on my island:

My (mostly) lovely neighbors, in order of when they moved in:
DomThis guy tries to be a jock so hard but he can't escape his adorkable fluffy-ball exterior. He's my ACNH BFF (and maybe something more? jk... unless???

) and I just want to hug him and hold his hand forever.

PashminaPashmina was one of my OGs from New Leaf, but she left Serres to travel the world. Funny we should wind up on the same island together all these years later. As one of my first two ACNH villagers, we've only deepened our friendship since New Leaf. She's indispensable for fashion tips and island goss, too.

RodeoI hate this guy. He's made multiple of my villagers upset, dissed my fashion the second day he knew me, and is way too full of himself. I call him a vampire but I wish he really was, just so he'd burst into dust after walking around in daylight.

If I get the Amiibo cards for my GC BFFs Bunnie and Hopper, this dude is toast.

SprinkleThe island ditz, Sprinkle can charm me and make me shoot soda out my nose in the same dialog box. I gave her her own special home placement -- the only house on the second tier of Ohana Isle, and secluded behind the hot springs to boot.

EllieI had a bad experience with the only other elephant in one of my towns, Opal, but I was trying not to discriminate...

I'm glad I didn't because Ellie is a true sweetheart. Oddly, she can be a bit blunt and oblivious to others, causing several of the other girls to lose their cool after talking to her, but Ellie's never been anything more than a good friend to me.

JulianI was a bit apprehensive about this unicorn bloke moving in... seemed like a bit of a weirdo, and also series-wise a bit too outside the "normal" realm of animals. And despite being male, he's more on top of the fashion scene than anyone else on the island. (Not that there's anything wrong with that.

) I had to give him props for his house though, a full set of end-game zodiac furniture.
Over time I've warmed up to him more and more, and I look forward to talking with him now.
RoccoUnlike a lot of people I know, I'm not immediately put off by the gruffer villagers. In fact a lot of the time, after you get to know them, talking to them is more my speed than the cheery ones (for the most part.) This comes from my GameCube BFF Hopper being a similar tsundere archetype.

But for Rocco, even though I made a point to talk to him every day, he wanted to move out after less than a week!!

I was heartbroken. Clearly he's more of a softy than I expected, so I've been changing up how I interact with him. So far so good! If he wants to move away again after this, I won't stop him, but I did not want to let him leave us after barely getting to know us.
DianaReminds me of the Pokemon Diancie. She's a sweetheart with a killer pink bathroom furniture set... A bit meek but very thoughtful.
CamofrogMy weed dealer. He's great.

BobHow's Annie? How's Annie?! HOW'S ANNIE?!?