Same thing happened last year. And while the overrated list is mostly troll-bait, the top 10 games are usually good. Last year had Far Cry 2, Saints Row 2, Banjo Nuts and Bolts, Fallout 3, Sacred 2 and The Club.
But I do admit that I'm confused about infamous getting a mention. It never built up that fervor that other games do on gaf, or in general, and it's the best PS3 game this year.