You know what's a "dumb post"?
Yes your post.
When people constantly complain about a game they state they have no intention of playing and their criticism amounts to "it looks bland".
Welcome to a game forum where people talk about games...And the criticism has been that the world design looks amateurish and devoid of any real personality or feeling. Which yes means "bland", but is kind of a big deal for an OPEN WORLD game. Meanwhile, your defense is now "its popular!". Wow so deep and nuanced.
Yes, it's a visual medium, but the sales figures show that the vast majority of the audience don't actually care if it doesn't meet your lofty standards and are perfectly happy with the way it's presented. If you don't like it, then exercise your right to not buy it. No one is forcing you. Go and play whatever boring bland third person shitfest that you Sony fanboys think is great these days.
I don't care. I'm on an enthusiast gaming forum, I don't care what average people play. An average person doesn't care about any of the shit people here talk about or have an interest in. And I won't buy it, but I can still talk about it. As an enthusiast Nintendo’s brazen cheapness with this ip and the fact that they are rewarded ticks me off. Also as an enthusiast, it annoys me that we don’t get something that lives up to the true potential of “Pokemon rpg on consoles”. If you don't like it you can ignore it. But at least if you're going to attempt to insult me do it correctly. No one mentioned Sony games, so that's a pathetic ad hominem that has nothing to do with a person propping up things like Xenoblade X or Shin Megami Tensei 5 as games achieving far more on limited tech.
I'm sick and tired of people whose first question about any game is, "How are the graphics?" I thought we were all intelligent enough to leave that kind of stupidity behind in the 16-bit era. Looks like they are still around and still trot out the same tired old one-liners about Nintendo that have been used since the 1990s.
I would think an intelligent person would get that people respond to many different things. Story, graphics, gameplay, a combination. Guess not. Or rather it's just Nintendo fans who have to find defenses for incomptence.
And I'm always surprised that people are confused that in an interactive medium people care more about how fun something is to play than how the graphics look.
Well by your logic you're kind of wrong, aren't you. Call of Duty, Grand Theft Auto, Red Dead 2. Sony games. All top-selling games in part thanks to their production values.
People still play Super Mario Brothers because of the amazingly tight platforming and tight controls.
I also play games I grew up with and have nostalgia for. Since I didn't grow up with Nintendo I don't have a built-in bias for them.
Pokemon will forever remain one of the most fun to play games because of the way the game plays and how creative the whole concept was.
I mean the main criticism of Pokemon games has actually been how stale and piss easy the gameplay has been
If those games had shitty gameplay with great graphics, no one would play them today and they wouldn't be some of the most enduring videogame series in history.
People still praise Half Life 2 for its physics, animation, and character modeling. So it's pretty delusional to act like these aren't things people care about.
No one plays Black anymore and no one is asking for a sequel. The only people who give a shit about Zone of the Enders are just weird people who have a thing for Kojima. Gameplay is king and, in the long run, the visual style will never overcome a game that plays well.
Black has a following and plenty of its fans ask for a sequel as it shows up in "underrated games you wish had a sequel threads all the time". Based purely on its presentation. Yes people give a shit about ZoE because they like the style Kojima games bring to the table.
But I know according to you this doesn't matter because they don't sell well.
Gameplay is king.
But God of War sells more than Devil May Cry. Something like Bayonetta bombs.
Almost like there's a lot more to games than that.