Seems to me magus only ever plays games for story. Complains about Saints Row 2 because it's a gangster game, despite the gameplay.
Seems to me you should stick to adventure games.
character and setting are important,i love final fantasy 7 because it features this pessimistic jerk on a mission to destroy some power plant in this dystopian city,certainly not because "ATTACK KILL ENEMY!!!"
when you remove stuff like that from a game like says... chibi robo,you aren't playing an awesome game about being a tiny little robot,you are just playing a boring-ass platform with somewhat bad control!
spoiler (click to show/hide)
Radiant Historia ends up the same way - but we are brother and sister! I WILL SAVE THE WORLD! Snore... what boring JRPG...
Radiant Historia begins with a very interessing time travel premise,rest assured that if instead of time travel they throwed me "GO RESCUE THE NPC!" i wouldn't have give the game a single chance
radiant historia is a horrible game,it re-uses location a lot and abuses those 3 sprites it has by using it every single chance it has,and then it tries to hide this fact by having huge stretch that are only dialogue!
but i really like stocke character and the time travel premise and the whole war suikodenishlike plot and so i want to play,it is a prime example of character and setting saying "yea! fuck you game!"
and yes the plot does fuck up near the end,i still think the game needs recognition just based on how so jrpgtrope unlikely the main character is