Is Peyton Manning the most overrated athlete of all time? He's consistently been an average to horrible performer under stressful conditions yet almost everyone in the media makes excuses for him. It's a joke how they preemptively defend against people who will unfairly label Manning a choker when the exact opposite happens. Manning is consistently placed ahead of Brady, Brees, Rivers, etc, regardless of how well they perform personally or how much they win. Sort of winning 3 championships in a row and getting another 5,000 yds/48 TD season, even Brady probably has no chance of surpassing Manning in all-time rankings.