Personally, I think there are some pretty big stylistic differences between here and GAF. Here, the inmates run the asylum. On GAF if someone is being a twat but doing it within the confines of "the rules" then there's not much to be done for it... they get to go on being a twat. Here, we have vigilante donkey punch member approved justice in that we can tell anyone to shut the fuck up and quit being a wanker. Shit like that gets you banned on GAF, even if you're right about the person being a wanker.
If we had a bajillion more members like you're positing, then maybe it would be a case where the administration had clamped down and established more rules. I think demi would totally do whatever for more money, games or pics of random bears. I just don't think he'd follow through on whatever he promised, because he's also lazy and doesn't like to do things. And in any event, if this place did become lame, everyone that's cool would just leave again.
Meh, enough forum navel gazing for one day.