I don't find frustration with the stuff in the thread at all, I'm used to it when comes to it and Shenmue. Being a Shenmue fan in itself is a battle with frustration. In any case, I still agree with my original assessment: that RDR is a tighter GTAIV in a western setting. I don't see how that's a slight on the game at all. In many ways it is GTAIV done right and expands upon many things that were originally in that game and does so in a more creative and memorable manner. You may disagree with that, but I have always felt that way about the game. That doesn't mean I dislike it at all - on the contrary in fact.
Regarding the empathy remark, that was only one thread for RDR and I bought the game a mere month later. The people in this thread have been trolling my Shenmue fanhood for years. Even then, it's a false equivalence.
But that's not too bad because it allows us to have some fuckery. It's just for fun, and I'm not overly frustrated.