I don't even get my music from Pitchfork, jewco. A coupla years ago I got into Arcade Fire and, gasp, Wilco, and have used Last.fm's recommended artists thing to discover new music. That and Hypemachine, and now Spotify, all tied up with recommendations from my friends. To sooner you care about Pitchfork as much as I do - aka very little, and you're showing you care more about them than you let on - the sooner you'll stop busting my nads for no good reason.
And Bitte Orca is far from my AOTY, but it was worthy of my list at the very least.