Ok, finished the game and the main achievements that aren't going to be annoying to do.
Really enjoyable game. I don't even mind the lol bioshock ending. When I heard the ending sucked I thought it meant it was going to be a non-ending copout with TO BE CONTINUED so I was glad that at least there was an ending.
+The stealth bits were great
+The fighting was fun, though the counter system on harder fights is too messy when someone starts an attack while you are stuck in a mid attack with someone else and you don't finish fast enough to counter even with triangle pre-pressed.
+The plot and story background was great, the patient interviews were the best part
+Graphics/Music/Controls generally good; detective mode is awesome
+Riddler Challenges were great, though the riddles were hardly riddles and more like "hey, go find the scarecrow's gas tank" lol. Still the super metroid exploration was super fun and broke up the main game
+Main game was well paced and varied
+Good length for an HD-gen game, especially if you explore and do most of the riddler challenges
+Challenge rooms are ok fun
-You didn't really get to "fight" most of the bosses which was kinda lame. But at least they looked cool
-Too many re-use of "throw batarang at face, dodge, counterattack" fights. Could've used some other patterns
-Backtracking to finish up the riddle challenges was more annoying than planned. Revisiting old areas when you have all your upgrades should be fast and painless with all kinds of shortcuts to get around quickly. Unfortunately they are not and having to go back and forth through the entire area again kinda sucked and made post-game collecting not that fun.
-Also the riddle maps kinda took away from the riddles challenges. Instead of exploring on your own like at the start of the game it became "go to this spot and you'll find the trophy/puzzle answer/secret message"
-The game was pretty easy, but then there was a decent amount of trial & error death parts and trial & error is always bad game design
Overall it was definitely one of the best, if not the best licensed game to date and a great game at that. B+/A- game imo. Can't wait to see what this dev does next.
Oh and Rocksteady must be huge Konami fans. So many nods to Kojima and Silent Hill. Which is fine cause both are cool in my book.