Let's imagine you've been watching Melo for the last 5 years or so though. Are you really saying you'd turn that guy down? He has his faults, but he brings one hell of a lot. He can get pretty much any shot, at any time...there's probably no-one else I'd rather have in the entire league than him with 10 seconds on the clock and a tied game. I get that those guys are good but in every trade you have to give up something. This win streak is nice but it's because of Amare going nuts more than it's because role players are suddenly being awesome. Don't get carried away.
I have no doubt that Donnie Walsh would trade everybody other than Amare for Melo, and he should. Sure, the depth chart will be shot to hell for a while but you'll have a great team if it goes through. There is no way the Knicks are contending this year anyway. Get Melo, stock up on quality role players in the off-season, and aim to knock off the Celtics and the Heat next season.