Yeaaap. Most annoying during the GOTY shows. "It's just..."
I'll never forget him filibustering Skyrim into winning whichever year.
I mean I don't really care which won and used to listen to those because it was the only times Drew was in anything back then, but you had Jeff and Ryan picking Saints Row: The Third, Vinny leaning Saints Row and Drew neutral. But Brad spent an hour or something talking about how Skyrim has to win, it's the only game deserving, no other game is on its level, etc. So they put it first to finally get out of there. One of the few times I've felt Jeff was legitimately angry over video games. And then Brad admitted he never played more than like fifteen minutes of Saints Row.

I always liked the part where they're narrowing their combined personal lists down to 10-15 games more than when they start ordering them because it seems collaborative. The whole thing is kinda crazy when their normal output shows that Jeff (and now Dan to an extent) is the only one who comes close to playing most everything.
Bringing in the top ten lists from all sorts of people including ZODIAC MOTHERFUCKER is probably the best part of their end year stuff. Very diverse perspectives from that.
I'll tie this all back to the thread...I could see this game ending up quite high on their collective list, maybe winning, and on lots of the lists in general. (I imagine Zelda and Destiny 2 winning the East and West divisions if they stay separate.) Unless some updates just break it, or if it really is more of a short term game of the moment.