I played SA1 and 2. They arent great, they are 100% mediocre. And I was a huge Dreamcast/Sega fanboy back in the day. Those games were ass with only a few good stages.
The Sega thirst was pretty real for me then.
Playing SA for the first time was practically a Mario 64 moment for me. But then again, the hype was trill when it came to the generational leap from Saturn to DC. Damn, I miss those days. Needless to say, I just still want a proper Sega redemption, but the days of Sonic could be gone for me... I dunno. As much as I loved Sonic 1-3, I wasn't feeling Mania. As good of a 2D Sonic it is, like Shenmue, they just need to remain in the past and settle where their trail blaze ended.
Speaking of Sega, as much as I would've said I want a proper Phantasy Star 5 or a Panzer Dragoon Remake, they'd never live up to the expectations now having waited this long.