The Box is straight up crazy, its like the Donnie Darko auteur got a discarded Shymalan (actually a Twilight Zone episode, but that is a typical Shymalan story) script and decided he could do one better. The movie veers wildly from full-on brilliant to stupefyingly distinguished mentally-challenged, often within the same minute. Its a wannabe mind blower that doesn't know it already was well ahead of the game going just by the supposedly normality of the early stuff before shit gets weird, and then it gets mega weird.
Its got a distractingly accented Cameron Diaz that would normally be a major fault, but in the Off-The-Railsvile that Richard Kelley crafts she fits in quite nicely. Its got a fantastic score and period design, so even when things onscreen are of questionable value (very often) at least its a pleasure to sit through.
The Box is a movie I actually really liked, but I tend to like films that aren't afraid to go full-on nutso to entertain me. The difference between a successful wackadoo movie like this and utter dreck like Revolver is hard to quantify, but you'll know it when you see it. Your milage may vary.
***