Evilore should ape Lowtax and let people buy other users mean spirited avatars and titles for $$$.
He'd be swimming in money.
Hillaries, Hillaries everywhere.
I am actually kind of open to the idea of GAF-Gold as opposed to an ad-funded forum. Lets say it was a $20 annual fee or $50 life-time membership, I would be OK with that considering the amount of time I spent posting there. But I don't see how that would work with the current moderation policy of banning people for wrong-think. So if EviLore is thinking along those lines to get away from the ad-block problem then allowing the current moderation regime makes even less sense.
As long as NeoGAF is free you can have a throw-away attitude but once you start paying for the privilege you want the fucking website to be an actual nexus of hardcore gamers and industry people and not chase everyone worth a damn away.

Neogaf will never convert all of its userbase at those fees. Most likely scenario is the site having a free layer on top of whatever sub they sell. They need the manic creation of threads on gaming side & the traffic from lurkers using GAF as an aggregate of all news, I'd say the standing and relevance of the board stems mainly from it.
Could actually make it worse in terms to moderation double standards, shitty drama over bans and a core group of paid "elite" users brigading discussion at every turn.
I have seen a couple of videogame news site & boards make that switch (to subs but with decent access for free users) and it never ever improved quality of the forums, quite the contrary.