William Henry Harrison got the same score across all three partisan groups, despite being in office for only a month and dying before Congress even came into session (other than a temporary one to approve his cabinet before he got sick), you can't give him 19 for that, you either leave him off or score him perfect, no inbetweens.
We're never going to get Wilson below 50% are we. 72/62/61 smh
They never ask for reasons on these, even if just for top five or so, plus recent W. and Obama or whatever. I still like that WSJ book for at least having someone write a case for every President which was an unique take on it.
Other than Trump, Democrats didn't rank a two term President lower than #31 (Nixon) and Republicans didn't rank a two-term President lower than #29 (Nixon) while Independents ranked one all the way down at #36 (Nixon). Next were W. Bush (#30 for D, #31 for I, and #23 for R's) and then Cleveland (#23 D's and I's) while Republicans went Madison (#22) before Cleveland (#20).
The highest ranked defeated after one-term Presidents are Adams (#15 D's and #10's I's, probably because of that HBO series) and H. W. Bush (#11 I's and #11 R's, though they didn't vote for him like that 25 years back). Republicans went for Taft next (#14) before Adams (#17). Democrats went for H.W. and J.Q. (#18 and #20). I's third place was also J.Q. but at #24. (Although technically, Obama at #6, #12 and #16 is the highest ranked non-legally elected President, as Hayes is down at #28 among all three groups.)