As for why PoliGAF is jaded... does it really need to be explained? Look what just happened a month ago.
Given how they treated posters outside of their community the last 2 years, they
really needed to be right this election. Not only did they need to be right, they needed to actually practice what they preached to not look like hypocrites. Don't pretend to be the evenhanded adults in the room preaching slow, methodical change through many years of hard work and compromise
only to immediately bail out after one lost presidency. If you're going to condemn hero worship, don't turn around and do it yourself. Don't proclaim yourselves the only logical ones and claim to value rationality only to double down when proven wrong and start chugging more kool-aid. There is very little self-reflection from the regulars in that thread.
There
are posters in OT that didn't look like jackasses this election. Soul Creator came out the other end looking impartial and rational in the political threads these past 18 months or so. I can't really say the same for just about most of the cheerleading regs from PoliGAF. That benji
Trump thread is a fucking SLAUGHTER . Seriously. Start at page one.
They played the smug, condescending asshole card time after time because they trusted they would win. They didn't. Credibility gone.